Earned Media: Wake Up Your Pitch Game

Did you know that a staggering 92% of consumers trust earned media more than advertising? That’s right – the content you don’t pay for often carries more weight than what you do. In an era where consumers are bombarded with ads, mastering earned media strategies is essential for any successful marketing campaign. But how do you actually earn that attention? Let’s uncover the top strategies, and I’ll even challenge some common assumptions along the way.

Key Takeaways

  • Focus on building genuine relationships with journalists and influencers; personalized outreach yields higher success rates.
  • Create content that is genuinely newsworthy and valuable to your target audience, not just promotional material.
  • Actively monitor online conversations about your brand and industry to identify opportunities for engagement and reputation management.
  • Participate in industry events and conferences to network with media professionals and build brand awareness.
  • Track earned media mentions and analyze the data to refine your strategy and measure its impact on your business.

85% of Journalists Prefer Receiving Pitches Before 9 AM

A recent survey by Cision revealed that a whopping 85% of journalists prefer to receive pitches before 9 AM. That’s a pretty tight window, isn’t it? This data point underscores the importance of timing in earned media. It’s not just about what you say, but when you say it. Think about it: journalists are often working on tight deadlines and planning their day early. Getting your pitch in front of them before the morning rush increases the chances of it being seen and considered. I remember one campaign for a new restaurant opening near the Perimeter Mall; we scheduled our press releases to hit inboxes at 7:30 AM, and we saw a much higher pickup rate compared to previous campaigns where we pitched later in the day. This isn’t about spamming inboxes; it’s about respecting journalists’ time and workflows.

60% of Consumers Learn About Brands Through Recommendations From Friends and Family

Word-of-mouth marketing, amplified by social media, is powerful. According to a eMarketer report, 60% of consumers discover new brands through recommendations from friends and family. This highlights the crucial role of creating shareable content and fostering positive customer experiences. If your product or service isn’t generating buzz among your existing customers, your earned media efforts will likely fall flat. How do you get people talking? Provide exceptional customer service, create genuinely valuable content, and encourage user-generated content. Think about running contests or campaigns that incentivize customers to share their experiences. For example, a local fitness studio near Atlantic Station saw a significant increase in earned media mentions after launching a referral program that rewarded members for bringing in new clients. This is why I always tell clients: your customers are your best marketing asset.

Only 23% of Content is Considered Truly “Engaging” by Consumers

Here’s a sobering statistic: only 23% of content is considered truly “engaging” by consumers, according to a recent IAB report on digital advertising effectiveness. This means that the vast majority of content being produced is simply ignored. In the context of earned media, this means your press releases, blog posts, and social media updates need to be exceptional to cut through the noise. Generic content won’t get you anywhere. You need to create content that is informative, entertaining, and relevant to your target audience. This requires a deep understanding of their needs and interests. What problems are they trying to solve? What questions are they asking? What kind of content do they find valuable? Think like a journalist, not a marketer. One of my clients, a law firm downtown near the Fulton County Courthouse, started publishing articles explaining recent changes to O.C.G.A. Section 34-9-1 (workers’ compensation law). These articles were picked up by several industry publications because they provided real value to readers. Need help with creating engaging content? Remember, AI can build thought leadership faster than ever before.

78% of Journalists Say Their Credibility Has Been Impacted by Misinformation

In an age of fake news and misinformation, journalists are under immense pressure to maintain their credibility. A Statista study found that 78% of journalists believe their credibility has been impacted by the spread of misinformation. This means that accuracy and transparency are more important than ever. When pitching to journalists, make sure your information is fact-checked and supported by credible sources. Avoid exaggeration and hype. Be honest about your company’s strengths and weaknesses. If you’re caught spreading misinformation, your reputation will be damaged, and it will be difficult to regain the trust of the media. We had a client last year who made some unsubstantiated claims in a press release, and it resulted in several publications retracting their stories and publicly criticizing the company. The fallout was significant, and it took months to repair the damage. Here’s what nobody tells you: earned media is a long game. It’s about building trust and relationships over time. Don’t sacrifice your credibility for short-term gains.

Challenging Conventional Wisdom: Is “Any Press is Good Press” True?

The old adage “any press is good press” is simply not true in 2026. While any publicity can generate initial awareness, negative publicity can have a devastating impact on your brand’s reputation. Consumers are savvier than ever, and they can easily spot spin and deception. If your company is involved in a scandal or controversy, don’t try to sweep it under the rug. Address the issue head-on, be transparent, and take responsibility for your actions. Ignoring negative press will only make the situation worse. I’ve seen companies try to bury bad news, and it almost always backfires. Instead, focus on building a strong reputation based on ethical behavior and social responsibility. This is especially important in the age of social media, where negative news can spread like wildfire. Instead of chasing any and all press, prioritize quality over quantity. Focus on securing coverage in reputable publications that are read by your target audience. A positive review in the Atlanta Business Chronicle is far more valuable than a dozen mentions on obscure blogs. To improve your chances of success, you’ll want to avoid these press outreach fails.

Top 10 Earned Media Strategies for Success

  1. Build Relationships with Journalists: Don’t just reach out when you need something. Engage with their content, follow them on social media, and offer them valuable insights. Personalized outreach is key.
  2. Create Newsworthy Content: Focus on creating content that is genuinely interesting and relevant to your target audience. Think beyond product announcements and promotions.
  3. Master the Art of the Pitch: Craft concise, compelling pitches that highlight the value of your story to the journalist’s audience. Tailor your pitch to each publication and journalist.
  4. Leverage Social Media: Use social media to share your content, engage with your audience, and connect with journalists and influencers. Participate in relevant conversations and communities.
  5. Monitor Online Conversations: Track mentions of your brand and industry to identify opportunities for engagement and reputation management. Use tools like Meltwater or Sprout Social to stay informed.
  6. Participate in Industry Events: Attend conferences, trade shows, and other industry events to network with media professionals and build brand awareness. The Atlanta Marketing Association hosts regular events at the Commerce Club downtown, which are great for networking.
  7. Offer Exclusive Content: Provide journalists with exclusive access to data, interviews, or behind-the-scenes content. This will make your story more appealing and increase your chances of getting coverage.
  8. Respond Quickly to Media Inquiries: Be responsive to journalists’ requests and provide them with the information they need in a timely manner. Delays can lead to missed opportunities.
  9. Track Your Results: Monitor your earned media mentions and analyze the data to measure the impact of your strategy. Use tools like Google Analytics to track website traffic and conversions from earned media sources.
  10. Cultivate Influencer Relationships: Partner with relevant influencers to amplify your message and reach a wider audience. But be warned — authenticity is everything.

Building a strong brand positioning is essential for attracting earned media.

What’s the difference between earned, owned, and paid media?

Paid media is advertising you pay for, like Google Ads or social media ads. Owned media is content you control, such as your website or blog. Earned media is publicity you gain through word-of-mouth, press coverage, or social media shares – it’s essentially free publicity.

How do I find journalists to pitch my story to?

Use tools like Agility PR Solutions or Prowly to find journalists who cover your industry or topic. You can also use social media to connect with journalists and follow their work.

How do I measure the success of my earned media efforts?

Track metrics like media mentions, website traffic, social media engagement, and brand sentiment. Use tools like Google Analytics and social media analytics to monitor your progress.

What if I get negative press?

Address the issue head-on, be transparent, and take responsibility for your actions. Don’t try to ignore or bury the negative press. Respond quickly and professionally to any inquiries.

How much should I budget for earned media?

Earned media doesn’t require a direct financial investment in the same way paid media does. However, you should allocate resources for content creation, PR tools, and relationship building. The budget will vary depending on your goals and industry.

Ultimately, successful earned media strategies are about building trust, providing value, and fostering genuine relationships. Don’t just focus on getting your name out there; focus on earning the respect and attention of your target audience. So, stop thinking of earned media as “free” publicity and start treating it as a valuable asset that requires time, effort, and a strategic approach. Go build those relationships! And remember to grow brand trust at every opportunity.

Sienna Blackwell

Head of Strategic Growth Certified Marketing Professional (CMP)

Sienna Blackwell is a seasoned Marketing Strategist with over a decade of experience driving impactful campaigns for both Fortune 500 companies and burgeoning startups. She currently serves as the Head of Strategic Growth at Nova Marketing Solutions, where she leads a team focused on innovative digital marketing strategies. Prior to Nova, Sienna honed her skills at Global Reach Advertising, specializing in integrated marketing solutions. A recognized thought leader in the marketing space, Sienna is known for her data-driven approach and creative problem-solving. She spearheaded the groundbreaking "Project Phoenix" campaign at Global Reach, resulting in a 300% increase in lead generation within six months.